Skip to content
Witcher.tools

Whatsoever a Man Soweth…

Main questVelen and NovigradHearts of Stone

With all three wishes done, O'Dimm wants Olgierd brought to the Temple of Lilvani so he can collect his soul. You can only step in if you visited Professor Shakeslock at the Academy first. Shani gets you there. Then challenge O'Dimm and beat his riddle game, and both you and Olgierd go free. Skip the professor or stay out of it, and O'Dimm takes Olgierd's soul and offers you a reward instead.

Choices

2

O'Dimm comes for Olgierd

At the Temple of Lilvani, when O'Dimm claims Olgierd's soul

  • "[Help Olgierd.]"200 XP

    Only if you talked to Professor Shakeslock. You offer to play for both your souls, and O'Dimm agrees to do it his way.

  • "[Don't get involved.]"

    O'Dimm takes Olgierd's soul and offers you a reward.

O'Dimm's reward

Only if O'Dimm took Olgierd's soul

  • "Wanna be as swift as the wind."150 XP

    The Caparison of Lament, a saddle: "Place it on your steed, and you will ride swift as the wind."

  • "Never wanna go hungry again."150 XP

    A horn of plenty. Reach in whenever you're hungry.

  • "A bottle of vodka that's always full."150 XP

    A bottomless carafe.

  • "Make me rich."150 XP

    10,000 crowns. "Hm, banal… but all right, I gave my word."

  • "Wanna know where Ciri is."300 XP

    Only before you've found Ciri. She's hidden from him, but he offers advice on keeping her from a danger ahead. Take it and that's your reward.

  • "Don't want anything from you."

    No reward.

Walkthrough

5
0 of 5 steps done
  1. The Alchemy Inn

    Next

    O'Dimm is waiting at the inn and stops time so you can talk. He says your debt isn't paid yet: per the small print you also have to bring Olgierd to the Temple of Lilvani, and only then does the brand come off. He kills a drunk who interrupts him. Once time starts again, tell Olgierd's man that his ataman should come to the temple, south of Oxenfurt in a cave. He also says Shani was looking for you.

  2. Shani and the professor

    Optional, but this is the only way to save Olgierd. Shani is packing to leave for the front in Kaedwen. Ask what she learned about Olgierd. A Professor Shakeslock researched Gaunter O'Dimm for him and now lives shut in his house on Academy grounds, guarded by witch hunters. She talks her way past the Redanian guards at the gate and lowers a rope for you on the riverside. The professor's door is locked, so look for an open window. He's gone blind deciphering old records, and he explains the pact: Olgierd gave up his brother Vlodimir to win back his fortune and Iris. The one man who ever broke a pact with O'Dimm did it by beating him at his own game, with souls as the stake. The professor dies right after, and the witch hunters come in shouting for the intruder.

  3. The Temple of Lilvani

    Give Olgierd the rose or the painting. Either way he starts to feel again, and it hurts. Then O'Dimm arrives for his soul. The pact said he could take it once three wishes were granted and the two of them stood together on the moon. Olgierd points at the sky, and O'Dimm answers that they're standing on it: "Here, on the moon, our contract you fulfill." If you talked to the professor you can intervene (see the choices).

  4. O'Dimm's game

    3

    O'Dimm takes you into his own world and sets a riddle: "Cry, and I weep, yawn, and I sleep, smile, and I too shall grin." Find him before the sand runs out: 6.5 minutes on Story and Sword, 7.5 on Just the Story, 8 on Blood and Broken Bones and 7 on Death March. When time runs out, you die. Lights pull you towards a family tomb, a swing, a well, a sword and some coins, and Shani's voice calls for help. Each one is a wrong guess or bait. Shades and a hym attack along the way. The answer is a reflection, but every mirror in the crypt shatters when you reach it. After three, Geralt wonders how O'Dimm could shatter a sheet of water. Find the dry fountain and break down the wall that holds back the water behind it. Once the fountain fills, you've got him. Your brand is gone. Some time later, Olgierd thanks you with his family sabre, Iris (200 XP).

  5. O'Dimm's reward

    Stay out of it, or skip the professor so you never get the chance, and O'Dimm takes Olgierd's soul. He removes your brand and asks what reward you want (see the choices).

Rewards

Achievement: Pacta Sunt Servanda

One of these, depending on the the ending

Saved Olgierd200 XPIris
Wished to be swift as the wind150 XPCaparison of Lament
Wished never to go hungry150 XPHorn of Plenty
Wished for endless vodka150 XPBottomless carafe
Wished to be rich150 XP10000
Asked about Ciri300 XP

At most 300 XP and 10000 crowns in one playthrough.

Tips

  • O'Dimm's advice about Ciri lines up with the moments that decide her ending: make her laugh when she's defeated (the snowball fight), let her vent her rage when someone betrays her (Avallac'h's lab), grieve with her for a friend (Skjall's grave), give her courage without acting for her (meeting the Lodge alone), and never let her feel sold out (Emhyr's money).
  • If you took the rose in Scenes From a Marriage, the cat and dog told you to "seek salvation in glass that can't be broken." That's the riddle's answer: a reflection in water.

All objectives

7
  1. 1Meet Olgierd's man at the Alchemy Inn.Oxenfurt Harbor
  2. 2Meet Olgierd at the Temple of Lilvani.Benek
  3. 3Find the solution to Master Mirror's riddle.
  4. 4(Optional) Talk to Shani at her home.Oxenfurt Harbor
  5. 5(Optional) Follow Shani to the Academy.Oxenfurt Harbor
  6. 6(Optional) Enter the Academy grounds.Western Gate
  7. 7(Optional) Enter Professor Shakeslock's house.Western Gate

Journal

Having completed all of Olgierd von Everec's wishes, Geralt went to the Alchemy Inn, where he was to meet with the ataman's representative...

With Shani's help, Geralt managed to enter the Academy grounds and speak to a Professor Shakeslock, who had earlier helped Olgierd in his attempts to break the pact with Master Mirror. The professor revealed that O'Dimm could be cheated – one needed only propose a wager, and, as an inveterate gambler, he was ligely to agree to take one up on it.

Geralt took Professor Shakeslock's advice and proposed a wager to Master Mirror. Mirror agreed, but only if it was played out on his terms. He transported Geralt to a strange, dark world and made him solve a riddle. Geralt, who has always had a keen mind for such puzzles, soon found the solution and defeated Gaunter O'Dimm. Was this the last our world will ever see of him? No man can say...

What mattered most at the moment, however, was that Olgierd von Everec was safe, and the pact which had bound him had been dissolved.

Geralt decided not to dispute the arrangement between Gaunter O'Dimm and Olgierd. The pact was fulfilled, and Olgierd's life came to an end.

To Geralt's surprise, he found Master Mirror waiting for him there. So that they might chat undisturbed, Mirror raised a hand and... stopped time. If prior to this Geralt had had any doubts O'Dimm was a demonic creature, this act – and the dark talk that followed – surely erased them.

Mirror made it clear Geralt had no choice but to see their bargain through to the end. Whether as an implied threat or just for some twisted fun, O'Dimm then killed a nearby man... with a spoon.

Geralt knew he had to do as Mirror asked. First, however, he decided he should visit Shani, who, according to Olgierd's messenger, wanted to meet with him.