In the Eternal Fire's Shadow
A young deacon of the Eternal Fire asks Geralt to clear the Devil's Pit, an old mine where the Church once walled up victims of the scarlet fog. Inside is Reinald, a Wolf School witcher the Church hired to drive out a red miasmal and then sealed in with it, three hundred years ago. Free his spirit, then decide whether he gets to face the deacon. That talk can end in forgiveness or with the boy dead.
Choices
4Reinald's request
In the salt cavern, if you made Reinald's Philter
- "Fine. Drink this."
The real Reinald breaks through for a moment: it was never him asking. Then the fight starts.
- "Not giving you the potion."
Geralt keeps it, and the fight starts.
- "[Test Reinald] Found your letters to... Lambert."
Only after reading Reinald's third or fourth letter, and only if Lambert is alive. The miasmal takes the bait, and Geralt knows he isn't talking to Reinald.
Reinald's last wish
Once his spirit is free and you've asked him to prove who he is
- "Fine. I'll get the priest."
Bring the deacon down. It can end well or very badly.
- "No. Not worth the risk."
Burn his body. The deacon is safe and pays you.
Your first answer
When Reinald calls the Church criminals and hypocrites
- "Found a priest who sacrificed his life."
Optional, only after reading the priest's testament in the mine. Reinald points out the Church sealed him in too, but it counts in the deacon's favor. You still pick one of the answers below.
- "Boy's innocent."
Counts for the deacon, double if you asked him at the start why a priest would hire a mutant.
- "Reinald's right."
Counts for nothing.
- "Not all priests are wicked."
Not always offered. Counts for nothing.
Your second answer
When the deacon asks what he should do now
- "What would you do, Reinald?"
Optional, asked before your answer. Counts for the deacon.
- "Don't need a church to do good, priest."
Counts for the deacon. If he has three points now, Reinald forgives him. If not, Reinald kills him.
- "Crimes like these can't be forgiven."
Counts for nothing. The deacon still lives if he already has three points.
Walkthrough
6The deacon
NextAt the Devil's Pit in Velen a deacon, two months out of seminary, is stumbling through a prayer. The Church used the mine to shut away the hopelessly sick, and old records speak of a spirit that breeds pestilence in a salt cavern deep inside. Deserters have taken the Pit, killed the sick and his escort, and he's afraid they'll open the mine. He offers coin, and you can haggle. Ask him "A priest asking a mutant for help?" before you agree, because his answer counts for him at the end (see the tips). He gives you the key to the gate.
The mine
1112A voice begs you to hurry and keeps steering you to the right-hand passages, and it gets angry when you go anywhere else. Explore anyway. Notes and letters along the way are from Reinald, a witcher of the Wolf School, and the tunnels show what the Church did here: Wolf School insignia, a torture chair, walls scored by the fingernails of people walled in alive. Keira's magic lamp shows more if you have it. A note near the entrance mentions a potion brewed with celandine. In a room deeper in, plague victims attack, and the chest there holds Reinald's Secret Ingredient and his recipe for Reinald's Philter: a Dwarven spirit, four Celandine and the ingredient. It raises Sign intensity and speeds Stamina regeneration. Also look for the testament of a priest who chose to stay with the sick, because it gives you an argument at the end.
Reinald
Reinald is pinned inside salt stalagmites in the cavern. Break them with Aard and he begs you to end the miasmal inside him (see the choices). He says he trapped it in a chamber carved in salt, where it couldn't get out. Then the miasmal takes over and attacks. Trap him in Yrden, then hit him with Aard to force the specter out, as the real Reinald shouts at you to. Then kill the red miasmal itself, which teleports and keeps summoning plague victims.
Reinald's ghost
Reinald's spirit thanks you, and asks whether his friend Osmund sent you. He thinks he's been down here a decade at most, and it's been over three hundred years. Ask him to prove who he is and he gives you the diagrams in his tunic pocket: the Forgotten Wolven set, two swords, armor, gauntlets, trousers and boots. He's free of the miasmal but far from at peace, and he wants a word with the deacon (see the choices).
If you burn his body
Geralt burns Reinald's body before he can become a vengeful wraith. Outside, tell the deacon as much or as little as you like. He pays you (75 XP and his 200 crowns, or whatever you haggled), and Geralt tells him the chronicle should say Reinald saved Velen.
If you bring the deacon
Reinald says the Eternal Fire takes in only criminals and hypocrites, and the deacon is shaken by what he's seen. Whether the boy walks out alive depends on what you say (see the choices and tips). If Reinald forgives him, the deacon leaves the Church, vows to turn the Pit into a real haven for the sick, and pays you outside (75 XP and the coin). Later he preaches by the mine. If not, Reinald kills him and Geralt burns the bodies (75 XP, no coin).
Rewards
One of these, depending on the deacon's fate
200At most 75 XP and 200 crowns in one playthrough.
Tips
- The safest way to keep the deacon alive: ask him "A priest asking a mutant for help?" when you meet him, then answer "Boy's innocent." and "Don't need a church to do good, priest." That's three points. Without the first question, add "What would you do, Reinald?" or the priest's testament to make up the third.
- Read Osmund's notes and Vesemir's note at Kaer Morhen to get the mastercrafted Forgotten Wolven diagrams, and the grandmaster ones too if Blood and Wine is installed.
- The mine gates are locked again when the quest ends, so explore before you finish.
All objectives
13- 1Open the gate to the mine.Devil's Pit
- 2Search the mine.Hanged Man's Tree
- 3Look for clues nearby.Hanged Man's Tree
- 4Defeat the hostile beings.
- 5Find out what happened to Reinald.Devil's Pit
- 6Free Reinald.Devil's Pit
- 7Defeat possessed Reinald.Devil's Pit
- 8Defeat the red miasmal.Devil's Pit
- 9Search the rest of the mine.Devil's Pit
- 10Defeat the hostile beings.
- 11Read the red miasmal Bestiary entry.
- 12[Optional] Prepare Reinald's Philter.
- 13(Optional) Search the mine.Hanged Man's Tree
Journal
While passing the infamous Devil's Pit, Geralt overheard the desperate pleas of prayer - a prayer he answered.
A young deacon of the Church of the Eternal Fire asked the witcher for aid. It turned out a gang of deserters had taken hold of an abandoned mine, now long haunted by a mysterious specter thought to spread pestilence. Geralt must deal with this plague spirit or risk releasing it unto the world.
Three hundred long years had filled Reinald with bitterness and spite. He was driven by a singular goal: to exact revenge on the Church of the Eternal Fire in any way he could, no matter the cost. Shortly after meeting with the young cleric, the witcher's ghost murdered the lad in cold blood, destroying his own essence in the process.
In a peculiar twist of fate, it turned out Reinald, a witcher of the Wolf School, had already been possessed by the red miasmal for hundreds of years. Fortunately, Geralt managed to defeat the specter, thus freeing the soul of his ancient brother in arms.
Geralt dared not risk another life at Reinald's word. Instead, he salted and burned the witcher's body to destroy his tormented ghost, thus preventing it from ever becoming a vengeful wraith.
With the young cleric's aid, Geralt managed to quell Reinald's anger and help him find peace at long last.