Skip to content
Witcher.tools

Carnal Sins

Secondary questVelen and Novigrad
Missable. This quest fails if it is not finished before you start The Isle of Mists.

Priscilla is found mutilated on the night Dandelion's cabaret opens, the latest victim of a killer who burns out eyes, cuts out hearts and pours formaldehyde down throats. The trail leads through the morgue to Reverend Nathaniel, a torturer caught in the act. Kill him on the spot and the real murderer gets away. Talk to him first and you learn it was the coroner, Hubert Rejk, all along.

Choices

4

The autopsy

When von Gratz asks what you've concluded

  • "This was a ritual murder."

    Only after finding the coals, the formaldehyde and the egg. Everything centres on fire, and von Gratz says it: the Eternal Fire.

  • "This was punishment."

    Von Gratz wonders what sin could merit it. Geralt says that's the key to finding the killer.

  • "No motive. Murderer's mad."

    The hardest kind to catch, says von Gratz.

Eustace

When he tells you to piss off

  • "What was in his pockets. Tell me."

    Axii, needs Delusion at rank 2. He shows you the note.

  • "Tell me what you found. Here's some coin."

    200 crowns, and he shows you the note.

  • "I'd advise you not to piss me off."

    He isn't scared of you or the crematory.

Nathaniel

When he turns from Sweet Nettie to you

  • "Try it, asshole."

    You kill him without learning anything, and the real killer gets away.

  • "First, I gotta know why."

    Then "Seen your victims. You never stop at that." and "So who left the letter on Patricia's body?" get the truth out of him. Any other answer along the way ends in killing him.

  • "Just like that? No formaldehyde?"

    Only if you found both the brazier and the formaldehyde clues. It skips straight to accusing him, so you can ask about the letter.

Nathaniel's fate

Once he's told you about the coroner

  • "Leave her alone. Now."

    Axii, needs Delusion at rank 3. He unties Nettie, leaves his purse and goes.

  • "Can't allow it."100 XP

    You kill him (100 XP).

  • "No time for you."

    You leave him with her, and he promises no permanent harm.

Walkthrough

7
0 of 7 steps done
  1. Priscilla

    Next

    Priscilla is late for the opening of the Chameleon, and then a dockworker runs in: she's been attacked and taken to Vilmerius Hospital. Joachim von Gratz, head of surgery, says she'll live. She has a concussion, a cut in her larynx, a scalded throat and a lost eye, and she's not the first. A body with the same wounds and no heart came into the morgue this week. Dandelion asks you to find whoever did it and kill him. Von Gratz suggests looking at that body before the coroner gets to it.

  2. The morgue

    There's no way into the morgue past the guards without a pass, so von Gratz takes you through the sewers, where he's been doing some "preventive medicine" on the drowners. Upstairs, find the dwarven woodcarver among the bodies with your Witcher Senses: calluses, sawdust in his beard, clothes sticky with sap. Examine him with von Gratz (see the choices). His eyes were scooped out and burning coals put in the sockets, his throat was scalded with formaldehyde, and his heart was cut out and replaced with a scorched salamander egg. The coroner, Hubert Rejk, walks in: the dwarf was Fabian Meyer. Hubert and von Gratz loathe each other, and von Gratz notes Hubert hasn't aged a day in thirty years. Reverend Nathaniel arrives, and Hubert covers for you and sees you out another way.

  3. Three leads

    Investigate in any order (200 XP for all three). In the alley where Priscilla was attacked, a prostitute called Whistling Wendy and her brothers are waiting for the killer to come back, and they jump you. Find the brazier that was knocked over, a smell of formaldehyde, and a trail ending at a wall too high even for a witcher. At the woodcarver's workshop his brother Gus lets you in past his new fighting dogs. The body was posed by a pyre of his sculptures, and there's far too little blood. Eustace the corpse collector robbed Fabian's body, and he won't talk (see the choices). He kept a note he found on the body, written on human skin, that named Priscilla as the next victim.

  4. Patricia Vegelbud

    A guard brings word of another victim, Joris Aquinus, a theology lecturer laid on a pyre of books critical of the Eternal Fire. Hubert has waited for you to start the autopsy. Inside the body is another note on human skin, naming Patricia Vegelbud. Ride to the Vegelbud estate. Ingrid says her mother lost her faith after seeing the pyres and burned all her holy books. You find Patricia murdered and the killer running. Chase him until the estate's guards mistake you for him and stop you. Ingrid clears your name. The note on Patricia names the next victim and place: Sweet Nettie, at Crippled Kate's.

  5. Crippled Kate's

    Upstairs, Nathaniel has Sweet Nettie bound and gagged and is heating a poker. He's a torturer and he enjoys it, but he isn't the killer, and only talking to him first gets that out of him (see the choices). Asked who left the note on Patricia's body, he says only one man knew he'd be here: the coroner, who'll be at warehouse twelve on the docks buying formaldehyde. Then decide what happens to Nathaniel.

  6. Hubert Rejk

    20

    Only if Nathaniel told you. Hubert is waiting at the warehouse. He punished people he thought had sinned against the Eternal Fire: coals for those blind to the Fire, a salamander's egg for their cold, doubting hearts. He's a vampire. Kill him (500 XP).

  7. The hospital

    Back at the hospital, Priscilla is talking again and healing fast. She may even sing again one day. For now she and Dandelion will perform as a duo, him singing and her on the lute. If you killed Nathaniel without hearing him out, you later find another victim with a letter: "You sought a servant of the Eternal Fire. Yet you were blinded by its flame."

Rewards

Investigated all three leads200 XP

At most 800 XP in one playthrough.

Tips

  • The clues pointing at Hubert are all there early: he hasn't aged in thirty years, the killer jumps walls no man could, and the bodies are missing blood.

All objectives

21
  1. 1Talk to Dandelion.Gate of the Hierarch
  2. 2Meet Dandelion at the hospital.Gate of the Hierarch
  3. 3Talk to Dandelion.Gate of the Hierarch
  4. 4Go meet with Von Gratz.Oxenfurt Gate
  5. 5Go through the sewers to get to the mortuary.Oxenfurt Gate
  6. 6Find the dwarven woodcarver's body using your Witcher Senses.St. Gregory's Bridge
  7. 7Find Eustace the corpse collector.On the map
  8. 8Talk to Eustace.On the map
  9. 9Investigate the alley where Priscilla was attacked using your Witcher Senses.Tretogor Gate
  10. 10Examine the place where the woodcarver died using your Witcher Senses.Hierarch Square
  11. 11Examine the woodcarver's workshop using your Witcher Senses.Hierarch Square
  12. 12Talk to the coroner.Novigrad Docks
  13. 13Find Sweet Nettie at Crippled Kate's.Hierarch Square
  14. 14Enter Sweet Nettie's room.On the map
  15. 15Kill Nathaniel.On the map
  16. 16Go to the Vegelbuds' residence.Vegelbud Residence
  17. 17Follow Ingrid to Patricia's room.On the map
  18. 18Chase the murderer.Vegelbud Residence
  19. 19Go to the warehouse near the port.Novigrad Docks
  20. 20Kill the vampire.
  21. 21Talk to Dandelion about Priscilla's condition.Gate of the Hierarch

Journal

Hubert Rejk seemed like a kind, gentle and accommodating man - but in truth he was a bloodthirsty, brutal and murderous vampire, hiding a twisted and fanatical mind behind his never-changing mask of eternal youth. Geralt cut him down after an extraordinarily difficult duel, avenging my Priscilla's suffering and saving the lives of the countless others who surely would have died by this base monster's hands.

Telling this story, my dear reader, will tax me greatly. It is a dark and somber one, encompassing the greatest sorrow my heart has ever known. It all started the day of the grand opening of my cabaret. Everything had been spit-polished to perfection - all that was left was to wait for Priscilla, whose performance was to be the crowning moment of this glorious evening. Yet when the doors of the Chameleon burst open it was not she who stepped inside. Instead, it was a messenger from the Vilmerius Hospital. His face pale and his countenance dour, he informed us Priscilla had been badly wounded in an assault - and was currently tottering on the brink of death.

Geralt's investigation took him to Crippled Kate's, a pleasure house of questionable repute. It is there, according to the note left by the murderer in Patricia Vegelbud's body, that the fiend would take his next victim - a prostitute named Sweet Nettie.

Geralt entered her room and found the Reverend Nathaniel, whom he had met earlier at the morgue, inside. The situation was clear - Nathanial was standing over Nettie with a white-hot poker in his hand - so Geralt meted out justice to this cruel and perverted man without batting an eye.

Geralt's investigation took him to Crippled Kate's, a pleasure house of questionable repute. It is there, according to the note left by the murderer in Patricia Vegelbud's body, that the fiend would take his next victim - a prostitute named Sweet Nettie.

Geralt entered her room and found the Reverend Nathaniel, whom he had met earlier at the morgue, inside. Though the situation seemed unambiguous - Nathanial was standing over Nettie with a white-hot poker in his hand - Geralt did not let his emotions get the better of him. He spoke calmly with the cruel pervert until he could identify the true murderer - then killed Nathaniel without batting an eye.

Geralt's investigation took him to Crippled Kate's, a pleasure house of dubious repute. It is there, according to the note left by the murderer on Patricia Vegelbud's body, that the fiend would take his next victim - a prostitute named Sweet Nettie. Geralt entered her room and inside he found the Reverend Nathaniel, whom he had met earlier at the morgue. Though the situation seemed unambiguous - Nathaniel was standing over Nettie with a white-hot poker in his hand - Geralt did not let his emotions get the better of him. He spoke calmly with the cruel pervert, and in this way determined the identity of the true murderer.

Sadly, though Nathaniel was guilty of many sins, serial killing was not among them. Some time after his death Geralt happened across the body of another victim, one mutilated in an all-too-familiar way. This time, however, the murderer had learned from experience and wiped all possible clues to his identity. The witcher thus could not catch him, and the death of countless innocents, and my Priscilla's suffering, went unavenged.

How great was my gratitude when Geralt rushed off after that hideous fiend who had done such harm to my Priscilla! Yet days passed, and the witcher never returned with updates on the progress of his investigation. Soon enough, I had to confront the fact that we would never catch the degenerate scoundrel. Strengthened by Priscilla's improving condition, I focused instead on the hope that one day she and I would sing together in beautiful duet once more...