There Can Be Only One
A hermit on Lac Célavy guards a sword at the bottom of the lake and will only give it to someone who has proven the five chivalric virtues. Prove all five through quests across Toussaint, beat him in a duel on the water, and the Lady of the Lake gives Geralt Aerondight.
Walkthrough
7The isle on Lac Célavy
NextThe quest points you to the isle on Lac Célavy, near Chuchote Cave. A notice titled Test Yourself with the Trials of the Virtues! on the Beauclair city notice board invites anyone to come and test the rightness of their character, and at the tourney grounds you can overhear two knights, Bors and Percival, talking about a quest that begins on that isle. You can also just go there. On the lake Geralt finds he can walk on water, and a hermit who has guarded a wondrous sword in its depths since time immemorial. Only someone with the five chivalric virtues may take it: valor, honor, wisdom, compassion and generosity. Five stones on the shore carry an inscription for each virtue, and reading all five pays 50 XP.
Valor
2Any one of these counts. Beat the Maestro in Raging Wolf. Clear all three hanse bases for Knight for Hire (Filibert Fourfingers, Loth Halfbreed and Antoine Straggen). Keep Sir François le Goff alive in Feet as Cold as Ice. In A Knight's Tales, fight the witch of Lynx Crag and force her to lift the curse. Kill the griffin in A Portrait of the Witcher as an Old Man, both slyzards in Contract: Bovine Blues, the basilisk in Mutual of Beauclair's Wild Kingdom or the shaelmaar in Contract: The Tufo Monster. Fight the spirit in Equine Phantoms. Win all three contests at the tourney in The Warble of a Smitten Knight. When vampires attack Beauclair, kill the one fighting Delwyn of Creigiau. If Dettlaff dies, that counts too, credited when the epilogue begins.
Honor
3Any one of these counts. In The Warble of a Smitten Knight, enter the tourney as Geralt of Rivia and fight Prince Anséis' mounted duel, or keep Vivienne's secret from Guillaume. Tell Charles in Till Death Do You Part that it was "just a marital spat". Return the stones to the curator in Goodness, Gracious, Great Balls of Granite!. Fetch Hugo's condenser in Father Knows Worst.
Compassion
4Any one of these counts. Spare the shaelmaar in The Beast of Toussaint. Let Marlene stay at Corvo Bianco in The Hunger Game. Help the wounded Roderick in Capture the Castle. Let Hughes keep the stones in Goodness, Gracious, Great Balls of Granite!. Make peace with the spirit in Equine Phantoms. Spare the basilisk in Mutual of Beauclair's Wild Kingdom. Give the widow her husband's locket in Contract: The Tufo Monster. Ask Count Beledal about Clarissa at his exhibit in Big Game Hunter.
Generosity
5Any one of these counts. Tip the boy who brings the letter in Turn and Face the Strange (5 crowns). Strike a deal with the bootblack over his price in Where Children Toil, Toys Waste Away. Get Syanna's ribbon for her in Beyond Hill and Dale, by paying the match girl 500 crowns or beating her at gwent. Turn down the count's extra coin in Mutual of Beauclair's Wild Kingdom. Buy the portrait in A Portrait of the Witcher as an Old Man. Refuse payment from the hermit in Equine Phantoms.
Wisdom
8Any one of these counts. Work out that Milton's hideout is a greenhouse in The Beast of Toussaint. Lift the spotted wight's curse instead of killing her in La Cage au Fou. Free Daphne peacefully in A Knight's Tales. Get the brothers to talk it out in Father Knows Worst. Win the gwent tournament in Gwent: To Everything - Turn, Turn, Tournament!. Light the candles in the right order on your first try in But Other Than That, How Did You Enjoy the Play?.
The hermit's judgment
When you have all five, go back to the hermit. He confirms each one in turn and asks whether you're ready to prove your skill in combat on the water's surface. Say "I'm ready." and fight him on the lake. Beat him and he turns out to be the Lady of the Lake, who gives Geralt Aerondight again and hopes he won't lose it this time. The quest pays 300 XP and unlocks the achievement Embodiment of the Five Virtues. Once you take the sword the water stops holding you up, and Geralt drops into the lake.
Rewards
At most 50 XP in one playthrough.
Tips
- Virtues proven before you ever meet the hermit still count.
- The quest fails for good once every quest that could prove one of the virtues is finished without it. If that happens before you reach the isle, you find nobody there.
All objectives
11- 1Return to the hermit and have him judge your deeds.Chuchote Cave
- 2Wait for a chance to prove your valor.
- 3Wait for a chance to prove you are a man of honor.
- 4Wait for a chance to prove you are capable of compassion.
- 5Wait for a chance to prove your generosity.
- 6Fight the hermit.Chuchote Cave
- 7Tell the hermit you're ready to fight him.Chuchote Cave
- 8Wait for a chance to prove your wisdom.
- 9Investigate the isle on Lac Célavy.Chuchote Cave
- 10Talk to the hermit.Chuchote Cave
- 11[Optional] Read the inscriptions on the stones.Chuchote Cave
Journal
On the lakeshore Geralt encountered a hermit who promised the witcher a wondrous blade. To receive it, Geralt had to prove he lived by the five chivalric virtues.
Step by step, in trial after trial, Geralt demonstrated that he was indeed in possession of the Five Chivalric Virtues. It was an achievement, this cannot be denied, for many before him had tried to do the same, yet had failed.
The test culminated with a last, secret trial. Geralt had to defeat a hermit in a contest that took place upon the lake's surface. Soon after, to his great surprise, the old man proved to be none other than the Lady of the Lake in disguise. Geralt had encountered the Lady on his Path, though quite some time past. In gratitude for fulfilling her demands, the Lady once more bestowed upon Geralt the legendary blade called Aerondight.
While traversing Toussaint, Geralt encountered a hermit who brazenly challenged him to a duel. As you might suspect, there was more to the matter than the old man's sudden compunction to brawl.
After a fierce and beautiful fight, Geralt defeated the hermit. The witcher was then greatly surprised to learn the man was in fact the Lady of the Lake in disguise, a woman Geralt had encountered long past on his Path. As the hermit had promised, the Lady bestowed upon Geralt the legendary sword called Aerondight.
Witchers are not knights and do not share their priorities. This is probably why Geralt failed to prove he was in possession of the Five Chivalric Virtues. The mystery of the hermit's true identity remained unresolved.
Geralt overheard a conversation between two knights. One of them had recently undergone a mysterious trial. This had played out on the shores of Lac Célavy.
Though Geralt reached the isle upon Lac Célavy, he found no one there. Most likely he had waited too long to investigate the matter, and after all, we well know Destiny does not like to wait…
Many consider themselves courageous, yet when confronting true danger prove consummate cowards. Naturally, this applies in no way to Geralt, who faced mortal danger and vanquished it post haste, thus successfully passing the Trial of Valor.
At times it is hard to keep one's word and thus demonstrate honor when faced by temptation. Luckily, Geralt was stouthearted and successfully completed the Trial of Honor.
Mercy is not something folk expect of witchers. As it is, they were created to hunt and kill monsters, and the mutations they undergo as children customarily strip them of all emotions. Yet Geralt had always been somewhat different, so when push came to shove he passed the Trial of Compassion, for he had always striven simply to be a decent man in spite of all.
Paradoxically, it is sometimes easier to demonstrate valor or honor than it is to show generosity. For the fact is many are courageous and honorable simply to advance their own cause. Geralt, like all witchers, worked for coin, but always knew well when a situation required him to show generosity. No surprise, then, that he successfully passed the trial meant to test this virtue.
Among the virtues, wisdom is arguably hardest to prove, for many consider themselves wise, yet the world is full of fools. Geralt never thought of himself as excessively wise, and perhaps this is why he managed to prove this virtue was no stranger to him.
Upon a notice board in Toussaint, Geralt found a call to all who wished to submit to a Test of Virtue. The notice's mysterious author summoned any who dared to an isle upon Lac Célavy, where they would have a chance to prove their worthiness of character. He who successfully completed the test would receive a reward. Though Geralt had never thought of himself as particularly virtuous, he found the summons intriguing and decided to go to the appointed spot to learn what the trials entailed.