Skip to content
Witcher.tools

The Nithing

Secondary questSkellige

Someone has planted a nithing outside Lothar's hut near Rannvaig: a horse head on a pole with his first-born son Tjalve's name carved on the shaft. The boy grows weaker by the day. The curse can be lifted by whoever cast it, or turned back on them by carving their name on the shaft instead, which would kill them.

The choice

Turning the curse

When Lothar demands you turn the curse on Jonna

  • "So be it."

    Carve her name into the nithing. Tjalve lives, Jonna dies, and you lose her as an alchemist.

  • "Can't do that."

    Lothar leaves his family and returns to Jonna, and Tjalve lives.

Walkthrough

3
0 of 3 steps done
  1. Lothar

    Next

    Lothar's notice is on the Rannvaig board, or you can visit his hut southeast of the village. He swears he's wronged no one. Examine the nithing.

  2. The shawl

    Follow the tracks from the nithing with your Witcher Senses to a Skellige shawl, then its scent towards Rannvaig, where the trail fades. A woman in the village recognizes the shawl as Jonna's, the herbalist. Jonna doesn't deny it: she and Lothar lived together for ten years, then he left her without a word for another woman, and the whole village laughed at her. She'll lift the curse on one condition: Lothar renounces his son and comes back to her.

  3. The choice

    Lothar refuses: renouncing his family would strip his wife and son of honor and leave them destitute. He wants the curse turned on Jonna (see the choices). If you agree, carve Jonna's name into the shaft; Lothar pays you and invites you to dinner (60 crowns, 25 XP), and Jonna, also the local herbalist, sickens and dies. If you refuse, Lothar goes back to her to save Tjalve and tells you not to show your face around there again (75 XP).

Rewards

One of these, depending on the ending

Turned the curse on Jonna25 XP60
Lothar went back to Jonna75 XP

At most 75 XP and 60 crowns in one playthrough.

Tips

  • If you plan to turn the curse, buy what you need from Jonna first.

All objectives

9
  1. 1Talk to Lothar.Rannvaig
  2. 2Investigate the Nithing.Rannvaig
  3. 3Follow the scent using your Witcher Senses.Rannvaig
  4. 4Ask about the shawl's owner.Rannvaig
  5. 5Talk to Jonna, the herbalist.Rannvaig
  6. 6Talk to Lothar about how to lift the curse.Rannvaig
  7. 7Carve Jonna's name into the Nithing.Rannvaig
  8. 8Talk to Lothar to collect your reward.Rannvaig
  9. 9Follow the tracks using your Witcher Senses.Rannvaig

Journal

In Skellige Geralt met a desperate and broken man named Lothar. Someone had cast a powerful curse on his son, causing him to slip closer and closer towards the grave with each passing day. The witcher knew he had to lift the curse before it was too late.

The witcher discovered the curse had been cast by the local herbalist, Jonna, with whom Lothar had once shared his bed. Once again it was proven - something which I, dear reader, know all too well - that man knows no greater enemy than a woman scorned. Geralt was able to save the man's son, but the spell demanded a victim. The disease moved to Jonna, dragging her into a painful and premature death.

The witcher discovered the curse had been cast by the local herbalist, Jonna, with whom Lothar had once shared his bed. Once again it was proven - something which I, dear reader, know all too well - that man knows no greater enemy than a woman scorned. Geralt managed to convince Lothar to return to his one-time love. He had to abandon his beloved son, but in doing so he saved the boy's life.