Skip to content
Witcher.tools

Of Swords and Dumplings

Secondary questVelen and Novigrad

Éibhear Hattori, the best swordsmith in Novigrad, sells dumplings now because Ernst van Hoorn and his friend Cleaver control the city's smithing supplies. Get him iron from the King of Beggars, a Skellige bodyguard and a cart of van Hoorn's own crafting supplies, then beat van Hoorn in a brawl. Hattori becomes a master swordsmith and forges you a relic sword.

Choices

3

Haggling with Tinboy

When Tinboy offers iron for half the profits

  • "Fine. Let's get this over with."

    Hattori pays fifty percent.

  • "Let's negotiate."

    Geralt offers twenty-five and Tinboy comes down to thirty-five. Keep refusing ("Still too much.", then "Fine, no deal.") and he calls you back and settles for twenty-five plus a discount at the shop.

  • "Are you crazy?"

    Geralt offers ten and Tinboy says forty is final. "Too much." takes you to the same haggling as above.

The warehouse guard

At the warehouse door

  • "Yarpen sends his regards."

    Costs 200 crowns. He goes to the privy and asks you not to take everything.

  • "Oughta let me in."

    Axii, needs Delusion at rank 3.

  • "Gotta get inside."

    Only if you sided with Iorveth in The Witcher 2. He's heard about Vergen and gives you the password.

  • "Me? Just passing by."

    He won't be lied to. Come back and pick another line.

The standoff

When van Hoorn's thugs corner Sukrus

  • "Let's dance!"

    The fight starts.

  • "Sukrus, wait!"

    Sukrus won't wait, he has to save his brother-in-law. The fight starts anyway.

Walkthrough

7
0 of 7 steps done
  1. Hattori

    Next

    Hattori's dumpling shop is in Novigrad, and an advert for it goes up on the market notice board. Ask about swords and he shows you the ones he kept. Van Hoorn started with a small dockside workshop and couldn't beat other smiths on skill, so he slandered them, bought up their debts and accused nonhumans of being havekars, with Cleaver protecting him. Hattori tried to buy iron from the King of Beggars instead, but the man wanted too big a cut. Offer to help and he promises a sword fit for killing gods. He'll meet you near the crane at the docks after dark.

  2. Tinboy

    At the crane, Hattori takes you to Tinboy, the King of Beggars' man. His offer is steady iron for half of Hattori's profits, and he says it isn't negotiable (see the choices). As the deal closes, Cleaver's dwarves walk in: this is Cleaver's territory.

  3. The ambush

    Fight your way out with Hattori and Tinboy's men, through the alley and past the last group of Cleaver's thugs. Kill that last group before you leave the area, or Hattori is killed and the quest fails. Tinboy will still deliver the iron but has no men to spare, and tells you to hire guards until the bosses make peace. While he talks, Hattori runs off (25 XP and 20 crowns).

  4. A bodyguard

    Hattori has barricaded himself in his shop and wants a bodyguard: Sukrus, a Skellige pirate who drinks at the Golden Sturgeon and used to work for him, until Hattori refused him a bonus. Outside the Sturgeon Sukrus is brawling with a merchant who turns out to be his brother-in-law. Break it up and Sukrus wants to fight you instead. Win or lose, he buys you an ale. His price is a favor: get his coin back from the brother-in-law down at the docks, or smash the Skellige mead Sukrus shipped in for him. To get the coin, tell the merchant "Palm trees grow on Skellige." with Axii (Delusion at rank 2) and he pays with a letter of credit from the Vivaldi bank. Otherwise break ten barrels of mead and fight off his guards. Tell Sukrus it's done and he agrees to guard Hattori (10 XP and 10 crowns). Hattori pays the same again when you next see him, and has to sell Sukrus some axes at the wholesale price.

  5. Van Hoorn's warehouse

    Hattori still can't forge: van Hoorn has also bought up all the crafting supplies, more than he could ever use. Hattori wants you to "borrow" some from his warehouse with Sukrus's help, and says the right crates smell of ammonia. Sukrus scouts it and meets you near the Sturgeon after dark. There's one guard, a dwarf who knows Geralt through Yarpen Zigrin (see the choices). Inside, use your Witcher Senses to find the three crates that stink of ammonia and mark them with chalk, then walk out so Sukrus's men can go in.

  6. Van Hoorn

    Van Hoorn and his thugs catch Sukrus outside, and the brother-in-law takes Sukrus's side (see the choices). It's a fistfight. Don't leave the area until it's over: that fails the quest and Hattori never goes back to smithing. Afterwards Sukrus and his brother-in-law make up and decide to ship van Hoorn off to Skellige before he comes to.

  7. Hattori's sword

    35

    Hattori is back at his forge, and from now on he can craft master-level swords and has a shop. Ask "Can you work in peace now?" and he starts on your sword. He says to give him a few days, but it's ready one in-game hour later: ask "My sword ready?" for Blade from the Bits.

Rewards

Made the deal with Tinboy25 XP20
Sukrus hired (paid twice)10 XP10
Hattori's swordBlade from the Bits

At most 35 XP and 30 crowns in one playthrough.

Tips

  • Finish this to unlock a master swordsmith in Novigrad. If you fail it, Hattori never works as a smith.
  • Later, on Ard Skellig, you can run into Sukrus, his brother-in-law and van Hoorn trying to sell imported wine to Skelligers who only drink mead.

All objectives

40
  1. 1St. Gregory's Bridge
  2. 2On the map
  3. 3On the map
  4. 4Glory Gate
  5. 5Portside Gate
  6. 6
  7. 7Help Hattori to make a deal with his supplier.Novigrad Docks
  8. 8Talk to Hattori in his dumpling shop.Portside Gate
  9. 9Escape the ambush.Novigrad Docks
  10. 10Wait a day for Hattori to set up the meeting.
  11. 11Go to the docks at midnight to meet Hattori's supplier.Novigrad Docks
  12. 12Go to the docks after dusk to meet Hattori's supplier.Novigrad Docks
  13. 13Get into Ernst van Hoorn's warehouse.Hierarch Square
  14. 14Gain entry to Ernst van Hoorn's warehouse.Hierarch Square
  15. 15Use your Witcher Senses to find crates containing crafting supplies and mark them with chalk.Hierarch Square
  16. 16Tell Sukrus to take the crates.Hierarch Square
  17. 17Stand lookout.On the map
  18. 18Find out what Sukrus wants.Hierarch Square
  19. 19Talk to Hattori.Novigrad Docks
  20. 20Gather Sukrus and his boys.Hierarch Square
  21. 21Find van Hoorn's warehouse.Hierarch Square
  22. 22Defeat Ernst van Hoorn and his thugs.Hierarch Square
  23. 23Collect your reward from Hattori.Novigrad Docks
  24. 24Meet Sukrus by van Hoorn's warehouse after dark.Hierarch Square
  25. 25Talk to Sukrus.Hierarch Square
  26. 26Stand watch.On the map
  27. 27Deal with the drunk merchant.Hierarch Square
  28. 28Defend yourself.
  29. 29Return to your post at the warehouse.On the map
  30. 30Enlist Sukrus from Skellige as Hattori's bodyguard.Hierarch Square
  31. 31Convince the Skellige merchant to pay his debts to Sukrus or destroy his goods.Novigrad Docks
  32. 32Tell Sukrus you solved his problem.Hierarch Square
  33. 33Return to Hattori.Novigrad Docks
  34. 34Break up the fight outside the inn.Hierarch Square
  35. 35Return to Hattori later to see if he's finished your sword.
  36. 36Talk to Hattori about the sword he promised you.Novigrad Docks
  37. 37On the map
  38. 38On the map
  39. 39On the map
  40. 40On the map

Journal

A witcher without a blade is like a potter without hands, and thus they are always on the lookout for skilled smiths to reforge or repair their deadly limbs. One day Geralt encountered a certain Hattori, a former master swordsmith who had transitioned into the premade edibles trade. He decided to convince the man to give up this dough business and return to his former practice. Little did he know this would be the start of a strange and toilsome adventure involving Skelligers, dumplings, shady ore dealers and, I kid you not, crafting supplies.

During this quest Geralt had to haggle like a fishwife, mix with mafiosos, draw with chalk in the dark and dive into a portside brawl. Most of all, he had to teach a lesson to the man who had squeezed Hattori out of sword making. All this so that Hattori would give up that infernal dumpling scrunching and return to forging blades. From then on our hero could make use of his services, and I sure hope he did so often, for otherwise all that effort was for naught.

To a witcher, a sword is like a lover. He must carress it, care for it, devote some time to it each night. But as with lovers, there are times one comes across a specimen so superior and not one's own that one cannot help but consider replacing the old with the new. Geralt was fully aware of these principles, so when he heard about the legendary swordsmith named Hattori, a tingle ran down his spine, butterflies took flight in his stomach, and he resolved to find the craftsman.