There Can Be Only One
The version of There Can Be Only One you get when Geralt has already proven all five chivalric virtues before he meets the hermit on Lac Célavy: the hermit skips the trials and challenges him to a duel for Aerondight.
Walkthrough
3The hermit
NextThe quest points you to the isle on Lac Célavy, near Chuchote Cave. A notice titled Test Yourself with the Trials of the Virtues! on the Beauclair city notice board invites anyone to come and test the rightness of their character, and at the tourney grounds you can overhear two knights, Bors and Percival, talking about a quest that begins on that isle. You can also just go there. On the lake Geralt finds he can walk on water, and a hermit who has guarded a wondrous sword in its depths since time immemorial. Only someone with the five chivalric virtues may take it: valor, honor, wisdom, compassion and generosity. Five stones on the shore carry an inscription for each virtue, and reading all five pays 50 XP. If you've already proven every virtue, he sees it at once.
The five virtues
34596This entry only appears if valor, honor, compassion, generosity and wisdom are all proven before your first conversation with the hermit. If any are missing, you get the main There Can Be Only One entry instead, which lists every way to prove each virtue.
The duel
When you have all five, go back to the hermit. He confirms each one in turn and asks whether you're ready to prove your skill in combat on the water's surface. Say "I'm ready." and fight him on the lake. Beat him and he turns out to be the Lady of the Lake, who gives Geralt Aerondight again and hopes he won't lose it this time. The quest pays 300 XP and unlocks the achievement Embodiment of the Five Virtues. Once you take the sword the water stops holding you up, and Geralt drops into the lake.
Rewards
At most 300 XP in one playthrough.
All objectives
11- 1[Optional] Read the inscriptions on the stones.Chuchote Cave
- 2Return to the hermit and have him judge your deeds.Chuchote Cave
- 3Wait for a chance to prove your valor.
- 4Wait for a chance to prove you are a man of honor.
- 5Wait for a chance to prove you are capable of compassion.
- 6Wait for a chance to prove your generosity.
- 7Fight the hermit.Chuchote Cave
- 8Tell the hermit you're ready to fight him.Chuchote Cave
- 9Wait for a chance to prove your wisdom.
- 10Investigate the isle on Lac Célavy.Chuchote Cave
- 11Talk to the hermit.Chuchote Cave
Journal
Geralt overheard a conversation between two knights. One of them had recently undergone a mysterious trial. This had played out on the shores of Lac Célavy.
On the lakeshore Geralt encountered a hermit who promised the witcher a wondrous blade. To receive it, Geralt had to prove he lived by the five chivalric virtues.
Geralt proved that he live by the Five Chivalric Virtues.
In a duel that played out upon the lake's surface, Geralt defeated the mysterious hermit. To his great surprise, the hermit then proved to be no man, revealing himself to have been the Lady of the Lake in disguise. Geralt had met the Lady some time past along his Path. The Lady of the Lake bestowed upon him the legendary blade called Aerondight.
The witcher met a hermit threw down the gauntlet, brazenly challenging Geralt to a duel.
After a fierce and beautiful fight, Geralt defeated the hermit. The witcher was then greatly surprised to learn the man was in fact the Lady of the Lake in disguise, a woman Geralt had encountered long past on his Path. As the hermit had promised, the Lady bestowed upon Geralt the legendary sword called Aerondight.
Unfortunately, Geralt failed to prove he was in possession of the Five Chivalric Virtues.
Though Geralt reached the isle upon Lac Célavy, he found no one there. Most likely he had waited too long to investigate the matter, and after all, we well know Destiny does not like to wait…
Upon a notice board in Toussaint, Geralt spotted a mysterious notice inviting all who dared to undergo a Test of Virtue. All who wished to face the challenge, clearly to their character above all, were to find their way to an Isle upon Lac Célavy. Our witcher found the notice intriguing enough that he resolved to see what the test entailed.
The trial of valor hardly proved easy, but Geralt emerged from it victorious, defeating quite an extraordinary foe. He thus proved he was no stranger to the chivalric virtues.
The witchers' codex does not require its adherents to demonstrate honor, but Geralt was an honorable man in and of himself. As a result, he completed the trial for this virtue with flying colors.
Not a soul expects witchers to show compassion for the simple reason that their profession offers few opportunities where they even might demonstrate mercy, let alone should. Geralt nonetheless managed to demonstrate that he could show compassion when warranted, and thus also was in possession of this virtue.
Generosity is a hard virtue to demonstrate for the simple reason that it generally requires to demonstrator to bear a cost. Many show themselves capable of being valiant or honorable when it benefits them, yet when circumstances call on them to dig deep into their coin pouches, the purse strings turn out to be knotted tight. Luckily, Geralt was not of this ilk and proved himself a generous man, thanks to which he also successfully completed the trial for this virtue.
Among the virtues, wisdom oft proves hardest to find, let alone prove, for most consider themselves wise while the world is chock full of fools. Yet Geralt had never thought of himself too highly in this regard, just like that famed philosopher who knew well that he knew very little if not nothing. Perhaps this was why the witcher managed easily to prove he was no stranger to this virtue.