Skip to content
Witcher.tools

Lynch Mob

Secondary questVelen and Novigrad
Missable. This quest fails if it is not finished before you start A Favor for a Friend.

Villagers near Hangman's Alley are about to hang a Nilfgaardian deserter who came to them trying to trade his ring for bread. Talking won't change their minds. You can kill the lot of them to save him, or walk away and let them hang him.

The choice

The deserter

When you talk to the ringleader

  • "Release him."

    They refuse.

  • "Tried asking nicely…"25 XP

    After asking for his release. The villagers attack, and you have to kill them all to save him.

  • "Do what you want."

    They hang him. His body carries a letter from his wife Alveen begging Dilvyn to desert. She lost her father and brother in the last war with the North and planned to hide him at Iffan's farm.

  • "So long."

    Same as walking away: they hang him.

Walkthrough

1
0 of 1 steps done
  1. The lynching

    Next

    The Nilfgaardian army trampled the villagers' fields and burned their orchards, so they have no bread to give and plan to hang him instead. He swears he never wanted the war and deserted to get home to his wife and child. Asking them to let him go gets you nowhere (see the choices). Kill them and he thanks you: his wife had a daughter, Beatrys, just before the war, and he's going home. Geralt tells him to keep off the high roads and away from villages until he's across the Yaruga.

Rewards

Saved the deserter25 XP

At most 25 XP in one playthrough.

All objectives

1
  1. 1Kill the peasants.Hangman's Alley

Journal

Should a soldier be held responsible for the decisions of his commanding officers? Is collective responsibility justice? To us, dear reader, these are rhetorical questions. Geralt, however, often found himself forced to answer them - and quickly. For example, once in Velen he happened across a group of villagers preparing to lynch a captured Nilfgaardian deserter. Not for the first time, the witcher had to decide which was the lesser evil...

The witcher made his decision. He defended the deserter and earned the peasants' ire. They attacked at once, and thus in order to save one man he had to kill many others.

The witcher made his decision. So that many could live, he agreed to allow the death of one. He knew that, if he defended the Nilfgaardian, he would be forced to slaughter the entire crowd of enraged peasants and so merely shook his head and walked on.