Skip to content
Witcher.tools

Fencing Lessons

Secondary questVelen and Novigrad
Missable. This quest fails if it is not finished before you start The Isle of Mists.

Rosa var Attre, the Nilfgaardian ambassador's daughter Geralt met while looking for Dandelion, wants a second fencing lesson. She ditches her escort, picks a duel with real swords on a bridge, then slips away to a tavern full of Novigradians who hate Nilfgaard. Get her out of it, and see what she's really like.

Choices

3

Rosa's plan

When Rosa leads you off instead of training

  • "What about training?"

    She tells you to stop harping on it. Same walk either way.

  • "You're using me."

    She doesn't care. Same walk either way.

The drunks

At the Seven Cats

  • "Leave her alone. Piss off."

    They attack. Afterwards Geralt tells Rosa the men died because of her, and she says they got what they deserved.

  • "Take this coin and go."

    Costs 50 crowns, which they take as war reparations. Rosa memorizes their names and swears to have them punished when the emperor takes Novigrad.

  • "Apologize and leave."

    Axii, needs Delusion at rank 1. They apologize to Rosa and leave, and she still swears revenge on them.

Rosa

After the tavern

  • "Lesson's over."

    Geralt tells her she'll be using that sword often and to go straight home.

  • "And you wonder why the North hates Nilfgaard."

    She thought he understood Nilfgaard's sense of justice and is disappointed. Same ending.

Walkthrough

4
0 of 4 steps done
  1. The var Attre residence

    Next1

    This only happens if, when Rosa asked for another lesson in Broken Flowers, you answered "You convinced me." A day later, talk to the guard captain at the var Attre residence. Rosa has gone for a walk near Temple Bridge and wants you to join her there (10 XP).

  2. The walk

    Rosa is waiting with a squad of Nilfgaardian soldiers, her father's orders. She dismisses them, since she has Geralt of Rivia, the best swordsman the North has ever seen. Then she leads you off without saying where (see the choices).

  3. The duel

    On the bridge Rosa wants a duel like the ones in her novels, with real swords instead of practice blades. It ends when either of you drops below about a third of your health. Running off the bridge fails the quest. Win or lose, it's 25 XP. If you win she yields with only her pride hurt. If you lose she decides to call herself the Black Bruxa. Then she asks you to turn around while she fixes her corset, and runs off.

  4. The Seven Cats

    7

    If anything happens to her, her father will have your head. Use your Witcher Senses on her tracks, which lead to the Seven Cats Inn. Two drunks, Lucas and Kobe, are harassing her because they can hear she's Nilfgaardian, and diplomatic immunity means nothing to them (see the choices). Don't leave the area, which fails the quest. Afterwards it's 25 XP and a talk with Rosa, and there won't be a third lesson.

Rewards

Talked to the guard captain10 XP
Dueled Rosa25 XP
Rescued Rosa25 XP

At most 60 XP in one playthrough.

All objectives

7
  1. 1Go to the var Attre residence tomorrow to give Rosa fencing lessons.
  2. 2Tell the guard captain about the fencing lessons.St. Gregory's Bridge
  3. 3Meet with Rosa.Tretogor Gate
  4. 4Follow Rosa.St. Gregory's Bridge
  5. 5Defeat Rosa.St. Gregory's Bridge
  6. 6Use your Witcher Senses to find Rosa.Seven Cats Inn
  7. 7Defeat the drunks harassing Rosa.

Journal

Geralt had learned that Rosa var Attre was a passionate devotee of the art of swordplay. The fencing lesson Geralt had given her while searching for yours truly had thrilled her to the core - and left her asking the witcher if they could meet again for a repeat. Geralt had plenty of experience teaching young women with fiery personalities how to swing swords and so agreed.

Once they were done with their lesson Geralt was supposed to escort the young lady home. Rosa, however, was clearly still in the mood for some recreation and gave him the slip during a moment of inattention. The witcher knew he needed to find her - or land himself in a heap of trouble.

Rosa found out for herself that not all residents of Novigrad respect diplomatic immunity. The witcher saved her from a tight spot - but also discovered a dark side to her character. It was clear to them both that there would be no third fencing lesson.