Father Knows Worst
Two brothers outside a cave near the Rioux-Cannes outpost say monsters trapped their brother Hugo inside. Hugo tells it differently: their late father, the cognac distiller Victor Monnart, split his still into three parts to force his feuding sons to work together, and the brothers tried to cut Hugo out of the business. Whether the Monnarts end up partners or enemies comes down to you.
Choices
3The job
When the brothers ask for help
- "Fine. I'll help."
You go in after Hugo.
- "No time, can't help."
They give up on you and wait for someone else to read the notice.
Hugo's part
When he asks you to retrieve the part
- "Yeah, I'll help you."150 XP
Fetch the condenser from the hot spring for a small payment.
- "Not about to help you."
You head back without it.
The standoff
When Hugo asks you to deal with his brothers
- "Yeah, I'll make sure you're not hurt."150 XP
You fight the brothers and their men. The brothers are only knocked out. XP, but no pay.
- "No one dies. Not today."150 XP
The men turn out to be hunters from a nearby camp. The brothers make peace, pay you and invite you to the Clever Clogs, where the three of them run things together afterwards. Counts as Proof of Wisdom for There Can Be Only One.
Walkthrough
4Two frightened brothers
NextAnswer the escort notice on the Gran'place board or just come across the cave. Lucien and Auguste Monnart say the earth shook, they ran, and Hugo went deeper in. You can haggle over the fee (see the choices).
Finding Hugo
Kikimores fill the cave. Follow Hugo's blood trail with your Witcher Senses. He's wounded and convinced his brothers sent you to finish him. Victor hid the parts of his still and told each son where one was. When the brothers learned Hugo's part, the last one, was in this cave, they decided they didn't need him (see the choices).
The condenser
If you agree to fetch it, the part is at the bottom of a hot spring pool in the cave. Bring it to Hugo. He can't pay much, but promises you the best prices once the family tavern reopens. Returning it counts as Proof of Honor for There Can Be Only One.
The standoff
At the cave mouth Lucien and Auguste are waiting with armed men, and Hugo begs you to deal with them (see the choices).
Rewards
100One of these, depending on the end
300At most 300 XP and 400 crowns in one playthrough.
All objectives
10- 1Find out what happened to the missing brother.Rioux-Cannes Outpost
- 2Follow the trail.Rioux-Cannes Outpost
- 3Using your Witcher Senses, look for signs of Hugo.Rioux-Cannes Outpost
- 4Defeat your opponents.Rioux-Cannes Outpost
- 5Retrieve the missing part from the lake.Rioux-Cannes Outpost
- 6Talk to Hugo.Rioux-Cannes Outpost
- 7Talk to the men issuing the contract.Rioux-Cannes Outpost
- 8Defeat the kikimores.Rioux-Cannes Outpost
- 9Return the filter to Hugo.Rioux-Cannes Outpost
- 10Talk to the brothers.Rioux-Cannes Outpost
Journal
One day, while traversing Toussaint's charming wilderness, Geralt ran into two men desperately calling for help. As they told it, their brother had remained in the cave they had just hastily left. Nothing out of the ordinary, I suppose, if not for the fact that inside this sibling had been attacked by beasts. Geralt decided he would try to help the man.
As Geralt and Hugo were leaving the none-too-hospitable caverns, Hugo's two siblings, assisted by a handful of armed men, blocked their way. Fearing for his life, Hugo begged the witcher to teach his treacherous bastard brothers a lesson. Yet as we all know, Geralt has a strong aversion for unnecessary violence, so he turned Hugo down. This proved a wise decision - forced to discuss their differences, the three brothers settled their dispute and resolved to embark on an enterprise together.
One day, while strolling through Beauclair's bustling streets, Geralt spotted a notice - someone was in need off an escort as they wished to penetrate a cave. The task seemed none too complicated or taxing, so the witcher concluded it would be unwise to let it pass.
Geralt followed a trail of blood to find Hugo. Wounded by monsters, the man had sought shelter in the cave's depths.
Hugo begged Geralt to find a condenser, part of a complicated contraption his father had devised. Papa had cast this part into an underground lake.
One day, while traversing Toussaint's charming wilderness, Geralt ran into two men desperately calling for help. As they told it, their brother had remained in the cave they had just hastily left. Nothing out of the ordinary, I suppose, if not for the fact that inside this sibling had been attacked by beasts.
Before speaking to the posters of the notice, Geralt set out to do a bit of reconnaissance. Yet he returned to them quickly to find out what the job was to entail. The brothers, trembling in fear, explained that their other brother, beset by monsters, was trapped in a nearby cave.
I must admit that this time Geralt truly made a mess of things. He started by arguing with Hugo's brothers, and, when the dispute escalated and tempers flared, he abandoned the whole lot to their enmity and itchy fists. I never learned how the story of Hugo Monnart and his brothers ended, and Geralt never received any payment for the troubles he had nonetheless endured.
As Geralt and Hugo headed for the exit out of the none-too-hospitable caverns, Hugo's two brothers and a handful of armed men blocked their way. Fearing for his life, Hugo begged the witcher to teach his treacherous bastard brothers a lesson. Deciding that he should see the matter through to the end, Geralt fulfilled Hugo's wish.