Crime and Punishment
On a beach near the Ancient Crypt on Ard Skellig, a man is chained to the rocks with the tide coming in and harpies circling. Yorg swears he was framed for the murder of his uncle Gretter. In Skellige, killing kin in cold blood means a slow death by the sea.
Choices
2Yorg
When Yorg begs you to free him
- "I believe you. I'll free you."
He has no way to pay you but promises to repay you if you ever meet again (10 XP).
- "I don't believe you. So long."
He begs you not to go. Leave the area and the harpies finish him.
Yorg's sister
After she confesses
- "He won't die, I freed him."
Only if you did. She swears she'll never tell another lie.
- "Learned your lesson."
Geralt tells her maybe that'll teach her not to tell stories about others.
Walkthrough
2The chained man
Next1Kill the harpies attacking him and talk to Yorg. He admits he didn't like old Gretter but says he never wanted him dead. Decide whether to free him (see the choices).
The funeral
In the nearby village of Rogne, mourners are burying Gretter, a good man who didn't drink much, they say, and wishing Yorg had been flayed instead. A girl cries out that her brother was good and runs off. She's Yorg's sister, and it's her fault: she didn't like her uncle because he was fat and stank, so she told Yorg he'd done bad things to her. Yorg flew into a rage and killed him. None of it was true. What you tell her depends on what you did (see the choices; 10 XP).
Rewards
At most 20 XP in one playthrough.
Tips
- The journal places the beach on Undvik, but it's on Ard Skellig, about 160 meters from the Ancient Crypt signpost.
All objectives
1- 1Help the prisoner.
Journal
On a small beach on the shores of Undvik Geralt came across a man chained to the rocks, the tide threatening to engulf him. The man begged for mercy, swearing he had been framed for murder and unjustly punished.
In the village near the site of the man's punishment a group was preparing to bury the person the chained man had supposedly killed. Geralt's attention was drawn by a sobbing girl. He talked to her and learned the child blamed herself for her brother's death. When pressed for the reason why, she explained that her false accusations had caused her brother to fly into a rage and kill her uncle. In Skellige, there was only one punishment for killing a family member in cold blood: a slow death by the sea's embrace...
Geralt was convinced by the accused man's testimony and freed him from his chains.
Geralt did not believe the chained man's testimony and left him chained to the rocks, to meet his end at the mercy of the waves and the beasts of the sea.