Skip to content
Witcher.tools

An Unpaid Debt

Secondary questSkellige

Simun Brambling got Geralt out of Lugos' prison in Stranger in a Strange Land, and now he wants the favor back: kill Volund, the man who has hunted him across the isles for years. Do it, or refuse at the lake and kill Simun instead. Either way it pays 50 XP.

Choices

2

Simun's favor

When Simun calls in the debt

  • "Fine. What do I gotta do?"

    Simun sends you to the hut by the lake.

  • "Count me out."

    Simun warns that breaking an oath on Skellige shortens your life. The quest never starts. Later, three of his men attack you with Simun's regards, and there's no XP.

Volund

At the hut, once Volund has told his side

  • "Nothing personal, just paying a debt."

    Fight Volund and his men. Simun and his own man stay out of it.

  • "Outta the question. I'm no murderer."

    Simun says you'll die at Volund's side, and he and his man attack. Volund fights with you.

Walkthrough

2
0 of 2 steps done
  1. Simun

    Next

    This only happens if you took Simun's offer in the prison. A day or more after the trial, Simun calls you over. He walked out of Lugos' prison on his own, and the debt is due: pay it or shame your whole line (see the choices). He won't say what he wants, only that you'll meet at a lone hut on the shore of a lake near Blandare, on Ard Skellig.

  2. The hut by the lake

    Volund is waiting at the hut with his men, and can't believe Simun walked in on his own. He'd tried to talk Lugos into handing Simun over. Geralt asks what this is about: Simun tricked and betrayed Volund's brother and killed him, and Volund swore revenge. Simun tells you to cut him down (see the choices). If you do, Simun thanks you, says you're even, and starts searching Volund's body for his old sword. If you refuse, kill Simun. Volund warns you that Simun has a cousin on Spikeroog who'll swear blood revenge if he hears, and Geralt has had enough of feuds.

Rewards

Debt settled50 XP

At most 50 XP in one playthrough.

Tips

  • Once the fight at the hut starts, leaving the area before it's over fails the quest.

All objectives

3
  1. 1Meet with Simun in the hut by the lake.Miners' Camp
  2. 2Kill Simun's enemy.Miners' Camp
  3. 3Kill Simun.Miners' Camp

Journal

Geralt was only able to escape from Madman Lugos' prison thanks to the help of a mysterious old man called Simun Brambling. It was he who convinced the guard to let Geralt out, warning Geralt first that he would one day demand a favor in return. Geralt had managed to forget about the whole incident - but not Simun. The old man found Geralt and demanded he repay his debt.

Geralt decided he'd rather stain his honor than spill the blood of an innocent man. Simun did not accept this excuse and decided to kill Geralt alongside his age-old rival. The old warrior underestimated the witcher, however, and after a short fight he died from wounds delivered by the witcher's blade.

Geralt did what Simun demanded - he killed a man who had done him no wrong. As you can see, dear reader, at times one must act dishonorably in order to maintain one's honor.