Skip to content
Witcher.tools

An Eye for an Eye

Secondary questVelen and Novigrad
Missable. This quest fails if it is not finished before you start The Isle of Mists.

Ves has gone against Roche's orders to defend Mulbrydale from a Nilfgaardian punitive raid, and Roche wants your help stopping her. What matters is how fast you reach her once the fighting starts. If she dies, the quest fails and Roche won't come to Kaer Morhen.

The choice

The Nilfgaardian officer

After the fight, when Roche and Ves argue over the survivor

  • "Kill him, Roche. I don't want any trouble."

    Geralt points out he sometimes works for Nilfgaard. Roche doesn't like it, but he won't let Geralt suffer for his mercy, so he kills the officer himself.

  • "Hard to argue with that."

    Roche lets the officer go, wanting Emhyr to learn the partisans can show mercy too. Ves is furious.

Walkthrough

4
0 of 4 steps done
  1. Roche's hideout

    Next

    After the chess club, Roche is in a dark mood and asks you to come to his hideout near Oxenfurt. Ves has taken a couple of the lads across the river to hit the Nilfgaardians at Mulbrydale, though he'd confined her to camp. The villagers helped the partisans, and word is the Nilfgaardians are coming to hang every fifth one of them. Roche thinks she's waiting in the woods and wants you to help him find her before she attacks. If you turn him down you can talk to him again and agree later.

  2. Hanged Man's Tree

    Meet Roche at the Hanged Man's Tree in Velen. The village below is already full of Nilfgaardians getting ready to execute people. Roche expects Ves to wait for dark, but Geralt spots three lightly armed figures creeping closer, and then Ves charges.

  3. Mulbrydale

    Run straight to Ves. She can't die at first, but her health is forced down on a timer: 80% five seconds in, then 60%, 40% and 20% at 25, 40 and 55 seconds. At 70 seconds it drops to 5% and from then on the Nilfgaardians can kill her. Once you reach her she can't be killed at all, so get there first and fight after. Don't leave the village while the fight is on, because Ves dies if you do. Then kill all the Nilfgaardians. Their officer won't die in the fight.

  4. The prisoner

    Roche tears into Ves for disobeying him and for charging in with her shirt open, and takes her weapon until she wises up. Then the officer coughs: he's still alive. Ves wants him dead and Roche wants to let him go (see the choices). Either way Roche thanks you and says you know where to find him if you need help (50 XP).

Rewards

Saved Ves50 XP

At most 50 XP in one playthrough.

Tips

  • If Ves dies, Roche blames you, and in Brothers in Arms he can't leave the partisans because there's no one left to stand in for him.
  • The quest fails if it's still open when you reach the Isle of Mists.

All objectives

4
  1. 1Meet Roche by Hanged Man's Tree.Hanged Man's Tree
  2. 2Save Ves.Temerian Partisan Hideout
  3. 3Kill all the Nilfgaardians.Mulbrydale
  4. 4Meet Roche at his camp.Temerian Partisan Hideout

Journal

Those under Roche's command rarely defied orders. When they did, the task of disciplining them fell to Roche's second-in-command, Ves. No one who endured a reprimand from this tight-lipped yet strong-armed soldier would ever think of insubordination again.

Yet this time Ves strayed from her usual loyalty and ignored Roche's orders by leaving her post without permission. Faced with an unusual dilemma, Vernon decided to turn to the witcher for help.

The peasants of Mulbrydale had helped Roche's guerillas in the past, so Ves decided to stand in their defense now, in their hour of need, though she knew this was a hopeless and nearly suicidal mission. Had not Geralt and Roche come to the rescue in the last minute, Ves would surely have died a premature death after being cut down by Nilfgaardians. Yet as it were, the imperial troops were defeated - and their leader was killed on the witcher's request.

The peasants of Mulbrydale had helped Roche's guerillas in the past, so Ves decided to stand in their defense now, in their hour of need, though she knew this was a hopeless and nearly suicidal mission. Had not Geralt and Roche come to the rescue in the last minute, Ves would surely have died a premature death after being cut down by Nilfgaardians. Yet as it were, the imperial troops were defeated - but their leader escaped with his life thanks to Roche's intervention and Geralt's support.

Yet Roche and Geralt did not come to the rescue in time. Ves fought to save the peasants of Mulbrydale - though she knew full well she stood no chance of winning against her substantially more numerous opponents. No historian will write of this struggle, nor will any bard sing of it, and no gravestone shall mark Ves' resting place.

Vernon Roche fell into dour spirits after Geralt's conversation with Radovid at the chess club. He didn't want to say right then what had blackened his mood. Instead, he asked the witcher to come talk to him at his hideout near Oxenfurt.

Though Geralt had promised to meet Roche at his hideout, he never showed. To this day I don't know if he forgot, didn't want to or simply had more important matters to tend to. The fact remains, however, that he never met up with Roche and never found out what the former Blue Stripes commander had been scheming.

Geralt's first reflex was to agree to help Roche with his trouble with Ves, but when he thought things over, he concluded he shouldn't get involved in an internal conflict between a superior and his subordinate.