A Towerful of Mice
Keira Metz sends Geralt to lift the curse on Fyke Isle, and the ghost waiting at the top of the tower asks him to carry her bones to her lover Graham. Agreeing frees a plague maiden and costs Graham his life. Refusing also ends with Graham dead, but his kiss lays her to rest for good and pays 200 XP more, which makes it the better ending.
The choice
Anabelle's request
In Alexander's laboratory, after Anabelle tells her story
- "Fine."300 XP
You carry her bones to Graham in Oreton. He dies, the curse lifts and the plague maiden goes free.
- "Not sure I trust you."500 XP
Only offered if you used the lamp on the looter killed in the tower.
Follow with "Got a feeling you might be lying." or "I won't help you." She attacks as a plague maiden, and you bring Graham to the tower, where his kiss lays her to rest.
- "Need to look around."500 XP
Leaving the room or the tower plays out the same way as refusing.
Walkthrough
8Keira's request
NextKeira wants the curse on Fyke Isle broken because the local peasants won't stop asking her to, and a witch who can't lift a village curse soon looks like a witch worth reporting. She can't set foot on the island herself, so she hands Geralt her magic lamp and a xenovox to talk to her from a distance. Pick "I'm off to Fyke Isle." to leave, or "Lemme think about it." to come back later.
Crossing to Fyke Isle
Keira's boat is moored on the lake shore by Midcopse. Drowners hold the island's beaches and more monsters wait along the path to the tower, so pick a landing close to the tower rather than circling the whole island. The bodies you pass on the way in are fresh, and nothing about them points at the monsters.
The seven hauntings
Seven spots around the island and inside the tower replay the last moments of the dead when you hold up the lamp. Each is worth 50 XP except the looter killed inside the tower, who is worth 100, so all seven add up to 400 XP. Don't skip the looter: something he never sees kills him while he's counting the lord's gold, and having watched it is what unlocks the option to call Anabelle a liar later.
The hidden laboratory
The tower is overrun with rats. Alexander's laboratory sits above the false top floor, and two levers there open the way up (finding it pays 100 XP). Use the lamp in the lab to bring out the ghost of Anabelle, Lord Vserad's daughter.
Anabelle's story
Anabelle says the mage was infecting rats with plague, that starving peasants stormed the tower, and that she drank a potion she believed would kill her. It only paralyzed her, and the rats ate her where she lay. She asks Geralt to take her bones to Graham, the fisherman she loved, so he can bury them. This is the quest's one real decision; the options are below.
If you take the bones to Graham
Graham lives in Oreton on the lakeshore. He admits that he let the peasants onto the island and never knew Anabelle was still alive when she drank the potion. Leave the bones with him, and before you get far a scream calls you back: Graham lies dead among rats, and Anabelle hangs over him in her true shape. Her remains are off the island, so the curse is gone, but the plague maiden is free.
If you refuse
Refusing, or walking off to look around, ends the pretense: Anabelle shows herself as a plague maiden and attacks, and she can't be killed while the curse holds. Keira tells you who Graham is, and he agrees to come back to the tower with you; you can travel together ("Let's go now.") or meet him on the island ("Meet you there."). Wraiths of the curse's victims attack on the way up because they blame him. At the top Anabelle asks Graham to prove his love with a kiss. He does, she returns to human form, and he dies in her arms as the curse breaks.
Back to Keira
Report to Keira at her hut. She asks one more favor, which starts A Favor for a Friend, and Lynch Mob fails from this conversation on, so finish it first.
Rewards
One of these, depending on the ending
At most 1000 XP in one playthrough.
Tips
- Missable: the quest fails if it isn't finished before The Isle of Mists.
- Keira lets you keep the lamp afterwards. Later quests use it to reveal ghosts, In the Eternal Fire's Shadow among them.
All objectives
20- 1Talk to Keira Metz.Forest Hut
- 2Find a way to get to Fyke Isle.Fyke Isle
- 3Use Keira's boat to reach Fyke Isle.Midcopse
- 4(Optional) Use the magic lamp to find ghosts.Fyke Isle
- 5Head toward the tower.Fyke Isle
- 6Explore the tower.Fyke Isle
- 7Find the mage Alexander's laboratory.Fyke Isle
- 8Use Keira's lamp to investigate Alexander's laboratory.Fyke Isle
- 9Examine the marks on the wall.Fyke Isle
- 10Take Anabelle to Graham.Oreton
- 11Talk to Graham about Anabelle.Oreton
- 12Meet Graham on Fyke Isle.Oreton
- 13Take Graham to Anabelle.Fyke Isle
- 14Use the magic lamp to contact Anabelle.Fyke Isle
- 15Talk to Keira and find out who Graham is.Forest Hut
- 16Defeat the plague maiden.Fyke Isle
- 17Tell Keira you've lifted the curse on Fyke Isle.Forest Hut
- 18Investigate what happened.Oreton
- 19Follow the plague maiden.Fyke Isle
- 20Find Graham.Oreton
Journal
A horrible curse had befallen Fyke Isle and the tower that stood upon it. Half a year prior, Lord Vserad had moved his court there, seeking shelter from approaching Nilfgaardian armies. While famine raged all around, the lord of Velen wallowed in excess and cared not a whit for his suffering vassals. The gods saw fit to punish him and, towards this end, cursed him. One day, a host of mice scurried into the tower and proceeded to devour everything, including Vserad, his court and his resident mage, Alexander.
The isle had been haunted since that day, and fishermen feared to sail the lake, putting yet another dent in the already battered local economy. The local peasants thus asked Keira to lift the curse, and she turned to the witcher for help. Enticed by Keira's charms and her promise of additional rewards, Geralt took on the task. The sorceress equipped him with a magic lamp he could use to commune with dead souls, gave him a firm pat on the rear for good luck and sent him off to lift the curse.
During his investigation of the isle, Geralt discovered the lord's daughter, Anabelle, was the key to lifting the curse. She had died along with the others and her spirit now roamed the tower's empty halls, trapped in this vale of tears by her love for a fisherman named Graham.
Geralt thought taking her remains to the fisherman would solve everything - but instead it led to catastrophe. Anabelle, he discovered, was not an unfortunate lost soul but a dangerous plague maiden. The wraith had tricked Geralt - when he removed Anabelle's remains from the tower the plague maiden was freed from her prison and ventured out into the world to spread disease and pestilence.
During his investigation of the isle, Geralt discovered the lord's daughter, Anabelle, was the key to lifting the curse. She had died along with the others and her spirit now roamed the tower's empty halls, trapped in this vale of tears by her love for a fisherman named Graham. Geralt lifted the curse by bringing Graham back to see his love, but the story did not end happily. The young man's kiss dispatched the wraith into eternal slumber, but killed Graham - for, as Geralt realized all too late, Anabelle's ghost had become a deadly plague maiden, a spectral sower of disease and pestilence.